Though I took that cheesemaking class a little over a week ago, somehow my first dairy experiment ended up being yogurt. I came across a post on whip up last week about making yogurt at home, and it seemed simple enough – and only required two ingredients. I’m all for two ingredient cooking projects!
The recipe from JCasa *handmade is simple to follow, and it makes a tangy and delicious Greek-style yogurt. It’s a family recipe passed down through several generations, which is pretty awesome. I was a little disappointed by the recipe, as she says it will make about eight cups and I got a measly three, making it much less cost-effective. It still diverts garbage from the landfill, though, as New York doesn’t recycle yogurt cups, and I get my milk in glass bottles that I return to my dairy. The only garbage from the process was the yogurt-coated cheesecloth that I used to strain the whey (which I stupidly didn’t save – next time I will not be wasting that!)
Her recipe called for a half-gallon of 2% milk and a 6-8 ounce container of plain yogurt. I buy all of my milk from Ronnybrook Farm Dairy, and when I was picking some up at the farmer’s market on Saturday, I noticed they also had containers of their dairy’s Greek-style yogurt. Perfect!
I followed JCasa *handmade’s directions for the most part, making a few changes based on some of the entry’s comments. I poured my half-gallon of milk into a tempered pot, and heated it until it was simmering and formed a skin, at which point I turned off the heat and moved the pot to a different burner. While the milk was cooling, I preheated the oven to its lowest temperature (150 degrees Fahrenheit).
When I was able to hold my finger in the heated milk for ten seconds without completely scalding my skin, I poured the heated milk into a Pyrex bowl, mixed in the yogurt, and put a lid on the bowl. I turned off the oven, turned on the oven light, and, after wrapping the bowl in dish towels, placed in on the center rack in the oven.
After I returned from an evening of hanging out at Joy’s shop, eating Tex-Mex, and seeing Iron Man 2, the yogurt was, well, yogurt! I scooped it into a fine-mesh sieve lined with cheesecloth, and so began the draining.
A lot of whey came out of that yogurt, so I had to change the bowl a few times. (I will save the whey next time. I will save the whey next time.) By morning, the yogurt was thick and ready to eat. As I mentioned above, I ended up with about three cups of yogurt, one of which I then put in a separate smaller mason jar to save as starter for the next batch.
Even with the smaller amount, it is nice to know that I’m putting less waste into landfills by making this: a little bit of unbleached cotton cheesecloth (which perhaps I could wash and reuse?) vs. 3-4 yogurt containers. Also, I’m sure there’s less sugar in this than in store-bought brands, which is another bonus. It didn’t take very much hands-on time, and it was a somewhat magical and satisfying process.
Plus, everything looks cooler in mason jars.







